2265

Source 

Social media has transformed the nature of artistic success, moving away from traditional institutional gatekeepers toward a system that requires constant social validation through public metrics, performative authenticity, and adherence to community norms.

1. Metrics as a Form of "Social Proof"

In the digital marketplace, an artist’s value is often determined by the principle of "social proof," where a behavior or person is viewed as more correct or valuable to the degree that others are seen validating them.

• Viral Content: Validation is primarily achieved through a "veritable cornucopia of hits". Artists who fail to produce content that goes "viral" or accumulates a large number of views often lack the perceived authority of a "bona fide influencer".
• Follower Efficiency: Metrics such as the "follower efficiency ratio" (total video likes divided by new followers) and aggregate engagement rates serve as quantifiable evidence of social approval.
• Symbolic Capital: This validation constitutes what sociologists call "symbolic capital"—resources based on prestige, recognition, and celebrity. This capital is essential because it can be converted into financial capital and is used to define an artist as an "insider" or a "genius" rather than a "hack".

2. The Requirement of Performative Authenticity

To be socially validated on these platforms, artists must navigate the paradox of performing ordinariness and transparency while maintaining a carefully managed public image.

• Consistent Engagement: Unlike traditional celebrities who maintain precise boundaries between their private and work lives, social media requires artists to reveal their "true self" to the public. This involves inviting fans into their "cerebral cortex and imagination" in a deep way to maintain validation.
• Bureaucratization of the Spirit: Sociologist Erving Goffman noted that public performers must often engage in a "bureaucratization of the spirit," ensuring a perfectly homogeneous performance that meets audience expectations at all times.
• Validation of Lived Experience: Modern "woke" culture, dominant among "symbolic capitalists" (professionals who traffic in ideas and images), emphasizes the validation of "lived experience" and expressed identities as a primary source of cultural capital.

3. The "Drum Major Instinct" and Status Seeking

The drive for validation on social media is often fueled by what has been called the "drum major instinct"—a basic human desire to be first, to be out front, and to lead the parade.

• Quest for Recognition: This quest for importance is the "vitamin A" to the ego. On social media, this instinct can become destructive if not harnessed, leading to "performative shaming" or "boasting" as a means of gaining status through the intimidation of others.
• The "Imaginary Audience": Adolescents and artists alike are increasingly sensitive to the "imaginary audience". Their self-esteem is no longer based on internal feelings but on how they imagine their peers are evaluating them.

4. The Risks of Social De-validation (Cancellation)

Validation on social media is precarious; it is granted by the community and can be violently retracted.

• Online Mobs: Groups of highly conformist players can coalesce in "screeching outrage" to punish those who break sacred group rules.
• Reputational Death: "Cancellation" is the maximal removal of an artist's status, symbols, and livelihood. These mobs do not seek to turn the artist into an ally but rather to achieve their "reputational death" to serve as a warning to other onlookers.
• Preference Falsification: Because validation is so critical, many individuals engage in "preference falsification," publicly professing beliefs they may not personally hold simply to avoid the social cost of dissent and to maintain their standing within the "it" crowd.